We publish our audit record because accuracy claims should be checkable. Every entry on this site runs through an automated fact-audit pipeline (accuracy audit → source-grounded repair → visual QA); this page is generated from that pipeline's own report, not written by hand.
This is a fiction/fan codex: entries describe an in-universe canon. Our audits check canon and internal consistency — external fact-checking does not apply the way it does on real-subject codexes.
Last full accuracy audit: 2026-08-26 · 30 entries checked · 8 flagged · 17 issues confirmed · 8 corrected · 9 still open
Calico Jack — The claim that James L. Nelson won the W.Y. Boyd Literary Award for Excellence in Military Fiction in 2004 for his novel 'Glory In The Name' is factually incorrect; he did not win that award.
Gold Hoarders — Allied crews do not receive reputation for sold items, only the selling crew earns reputation.
The Order of Souls — The Pirate Lord is not a member of the Order of Souls; he is a separate legendary figure and leader of the Pirate Lord's faction, not part of the Order's ranks.
The Order of Souls — The Ghost Captain is not a canonical member of the Order of Souls; spectral entities like the Ghost Captain are typically associated with the Skeleton Fleet or other undead threats, not as a member of the Order.
The Drowned King — The entry incorrectly claims the Burning Blade is 'beneath the waves' as a permanent location, whereas in canon it appears above water during the 'Flameheart' world event.
The Drowned King — The entry states Flameheart's fleet 'hunt for treasure' as a primary goal, but in canon they are tied to his conquest and the Ashen Dragon, not treasure hunting.
Skeleton Key — The entry claims 'The provided source material contains no information regarding an item named Skeleton Key,' but in Sea of Thieves canon, the Skeleton Key is a well-known item used to open Skeleton Fort vaults, introduced in the Cursed Sails update and featur
Skeleton Key — The entry states 'Origin=Forged from Captain's Bones and Dark Magic' — this is not supported by established canon; Skeleton Keys are typically obtained from Skeleton Captains or as rewards from Skeleton Forts, not explicitly forged from bones and dark magic.
Cursed Gold Chest — The Cursed Gold Chest can only be sold to the Gold Hoarders or the Reaper's Bones, not to the Order of Souls, Merchant Alliance, or Athena's Fortune.
Cursed Gold Chest — Players can still use weapons, tools, and equipment while carrying a chest; they are not defenseless.
The Ashen Lord Arc — The entry states that Captain Flameheart is the Ashen Lord, but in canon, the Ashen Lord is a title held by multiple figures, and Flameheart is specifically the 'Ashen Dragon' or 'Captain Flameheart,' not the singular 'Ashen Lord.'
The Ashen Lord Arc — The entry claims the Ashen Lord Arc began in 2020 with the 'Flameheart World Event,' but the narrative arc began earlier with the 'Ashen Reaches' update in 2019 and the introduction of Ashen Chests and the Ashen Lords as skeleton lords.
The Order of Souls Saga — The entry states the arc follows 'Captain Flameheart's betrayal and the rise of the Gold Hoarder', but in established canon, the Gold Hoarder was originally Captain Morris, not Flameheart, and Flameheart is a separate Skeleton Lord who was not betrayed by the
All content is fetchable as JSON at /data/content/ · llms.txt · sitemap
Spotted an error? Suggest an edit — reader reports go straight into the audit queue.